Skip to content

Who is the Winner of the Great Content Delivery Network Race?

The Internet has more than its share of misconceptions and half-truths. However, one of the most significant mistakes is the belief that bandwidth speed alone determines how fast a webpage will load. The truth is more complicated—your website’s load time depends on user bandwidth and the latency of your server.

You can’t control the quality of your user’s Internet connection. However, there is a proven way to improve the latency of your server by using a Content Delivery Network (CDN). CDNs support your site by storing and caching your content (such as images, CSS, videos, and the like) and serving this content from an EDGE location. The result? Your webpage and all its content loads faster and more reliably.

This leads to the natural question: which CDN delivers the right combination of value, reliability and performance? To learn the answer, I designed and conducted a series of tests measuring the speed and performance of four CDNs: S3, CloudFront, Fastly, and

How I Tested These CDNs

I created my test to simulate a typical loading task for a website facing low to modest traffic. Using an S3 server, I pushed a 100kb file and tested how many transactions the CDN could handle over a period of 90 seconds with 100 concurrent connections on a single 300mb/second link; I also measured the CDN’s transfer rate and response time.

The table below reveals my test results, but first, a few qualifications:

  • I chose S3 as the test server because of my experience with S3 as well as S3’s support from Amazon Web Services.
  • I chose these four CDNs because of their similar price point and my familiarity with them.
  • There was no “warming” of the cache by throwing a preliminary file at it to scale the cache upward. This allowed the test to better simulate a site with modest traffic experiencing a sudden rush of visitors.
  • My test did not include comparisons between the different CDNs’ features, such as the ability to invalidate a CSS file or security capabilities.

CDN Performance Results and Observations





7533 hits

12456 hits12131 hits

12284 hits





Elapsed Time

90.03 sec.

89.95 sec89.81 sec


Data Transferred

735.64 MB

1216.41 MB1184.67 MB

1199.61 MB

Response Time

0.95 sec

0.33 sec0.37 sec

0.39 sec

Transaction Rate

83.67 trans/sec.

138.48 trans/sec135.07 trans/sec

137.3 trans/sec


8.17 MB/sec

13.52 MB/sec13.19 MB/sec

13.41 MB/sec





Successful Transactions




Failed Transactions




Longest Transactions




Shortest Transactions




Amazon CloudFront emerged as the clear frontrunner, leading the pack in transactions processed, data transferred, response time, and speed. CloudFront also led the way in failed transactions, though the 108 failures represent less than 1% of transactions attempted.

That said, these results represent only one test in one set of circumstances. It’s important to try out different CDNs for yourself to find the combination of performance, features, and price that best fits your needs. If you have specific questions regarding CDNs or Amazon Cloud Services, our development team is here for you

The Atlantic BT Manifesto

The Ultimate Guide To Planning A Complex Web Project


Atlantic BT's Insights

We’re sharing the latest concepts in tech, design, and software development. Learn more about our findings.

Questions & Answers

How much does custom eCommerce cost?

A custom eCommerce store could cost anywhere from $12,000/year to millions. Variable factors include the amount of custom features, the complexity of design, setup investments, training, and maintenance. Check out how to determine the cost of a custom eCommerce store.

Learn More about How much does custom eCommerce cost?
What is the best web development framework?
Many people commonly ask “what is a framework in web development?” Web development frameworks can easily be confused with web development tools, languages, or parts of the web development stack (like .NET, PHP, JavaScript, or Ruby).
Learn More about What is the best web development framework?
What is the best programming language for web development?
If there was one “best” programming language, then everything else would be obsolete. The reality is that there are so many different programming languages because there is no “best” language for any situation.
Learn More about What is the best programming language for web development?
How much does web development cost?
Web development can vary from a few hundred to millions of dollars depending on what is needed. You may simply need some changes to something that already exists, or you'd like to build a large or complex application.
Learn More about How much does web development cost?
What is web design and development?
People often lump web design and development together, so what's the difference? As the Internet has evolved, the skills required to produce a high quality website or web application have changed.
Learn More about What is web design and development?
What is JavaScript used for in web development?
Historically speaking, JavaScript was only commonly but sparingly used in web development. The multiple browsers in use at the time each supported different versions of JavaScript and were slow to render more complex Javascript.
Learn More about What is JavaScript used for in web development?
What is React web development?
React is a popular JavaScript library. It is primarily used for building interactive user interfaces (UI).
Learn More about What is React web development?