Toggle navigation

Content Curation Contest Awards From Atlantic BT

Martin W. Smith April 5, 2012
Top Curator 2011 Badge First Content Curation Contest Awards
Content curators are artistic, selfless people who want to help others make sense of a changing world. The Atlantic BT Content Curation Contest was created to repay great curators who’ve make the complex understandable, who see and share magical patterns and who express the joy of content curation.Thanks to everyone who shared their curation, voted or helped spread the word!Our Content Curation Contest will become an annual event, so be sure to follow @Atlanticbt, LIKE us on Facebook or join our email tribe of great Internet marketers and web developers.
Curator Votes Award Links & Curation
Susan Bainbridge 691 iPad 2 Scoop.it, @eddebainbridge Most Popular Curation On Scoop.it: The 21st Century
Khaled El Ahmad 480 Kindle Fire Scoop.it, @shusmo Most Popular Curation: Social Media on Scoop.it
Giuseppe Mauriello 469 New Voices Scoop.it, @pinomauriello, Most Popular Curation: Social Media Content Curation on Scoop.it
Anise Smith 300 Top Ten Curator Scoop.it, @AniseSmith Most Popular Curation: QR Codes on Scoop.it
Mariano Pallottini 251 Top Ten Curator Scoop.it, @MarcheBreaks Most Popular Curation: Le Marche & Fashion on Scoop.it
Gabrella Sannino 242 Top Ten Curator Scoop.it, @SEOcopy, Most Popular Curation: Content Strategy on Scoop.it
Robin Good 130 Special “Teacher & Mentor” Award Scoop.it, @RobinGood, Most Popular Curation: Content Curation World, Internet Marketing Strategy 2.0 on Scoop.it
Michele Smorgon 82 “Great Ideas” Award Sccop.it, @maxOz, Most Popular Curation: Social Business Marketing, Digital By Design
Molly Freudenberg 70 Great Friend Award Craft Ideas Weekly (on FB), Most Popular Curation: CraftIdeasWeekly.com Craft Ideas Weekly on twitter
Karen Dietz 58 Great Storyteller Award Scoop.it, @kdietz, Most Popular Curation: Just Story It on Scoop.it
What’s Next?
We are creating profile pages for each 2011 Top Curator (all ten curators listed above) with special badges and limited addition t-shirts to let others know about their Top Curator award. Profiles will share traffic to any two links Top Curators wish and we will NOT “no follow” the link.Sharing traffic, ideas and curation with world class curators, entrepreneurs and Internet marketers is what we do for a living.Thanks again to everyone who participated in the first Content Curation Contest.Don’t forget to follow @AtlanticBT, LIKE us on Facebook and join our email tribeof great curators, web designers, programmers and Internet marketers.Atlantic BTRaleigh, NC

April 5, 2012

Curious about what content curation is all about? Read What Is Content Creation by Atlantic BT Marketing Director Marty Smith.

A Word About Scripting & Spam Votes
Our spam algorithm set off quite an alarm as we reviewed the Curation Contest Voting blocks. Large blocks of votes from the same IP address coming in every second on the second for hours were kicked out right away. Several of these attacks came from places you probably are not planning to vacation.

Once it was clear the contest had been bombed by hackers we inspected the result set that came out of our algorithm by hand finding a few smaller blocks the first scrubbing missed (but not many and none that changed the overall results once cleansed). After using our tool and reviewing the list by hand (for hours) we are confident a fair result was reached.

The first Content Curation Contest seems a strange thing to attack, so we were using cookie based protection figuring why would anyone attack (script) this contest. The prizes aren’t that big and it is more a matter of pride. Apparently things get attacked because they can be attacked. No contestant benefited consistently or only. The attack was randomly spread across all contestants so the contest was being attacked not any contestant or contestants. Since the attack was the identifiable pattern it was possible to eliminate the scripted votes without impacting the organic vote totals. If a scripted or spam block got through it didn’t change the outcome since we went over those blocks laboriously for hours. Next time we will use IP based security from the outset and assume scripting in the voting pool. We will be less naive next year in other words.

I should have included this note about the contest being attacked on Thursday and the steps we took to keep it fair, but, frankly, I was dead tired after spending the better part of the day looking at IP blocks in Excel (not a fun task). I’m still working on ways to call attention to great curators who didn’t garner the kind of votes they deserve and creating a special exclusive t-shirt for the top curators of 2011.

Marty

  • Pingback: Easter Curation Tweets « « Web Marketing VoiceWeb Marketing Voice

  • http://docsheldo.com Doc Sheldon

    I was following this contest, and find in strange that the final count for at least a couple of those contestants are 900 – 1500 votes less than what was shown on your site prior to the end of the contest. What gives?

  • Derek

    Added to which, at least one person who had a ton of votes (perhaps the most?) seems to have been excised from the results entirely. I forget the name. But I question the objectivity of this “contest.”

  • http://ScentTrail.blogspot.com msmith

    Doc,
    Yes our anti-spam algorithm had quite the field day. There were massive large scripting blocks, like every second for several hours in some cases, that were eliminated by the math. Some smaller blocks may have gotten through so we inspected the entire result (post scrubbing) by hand. Seems like a strange contest to bomb, but bombed it was.

    Marty

  • http://ScentTrail.blogspot.com msmith

    Derek,
    I guess I can understand your confusion. You are right, I should have included the note I just did about the lengths we had to go to in order to insure a fair result on Thursday. As a cancer survivor I can tell you I value my days much more than the two I will never get back due to spending hours and hours combing through IP blocks in Excel thanks to some mean spirited hackers. We didn’t want to scrub the entire contest as that seemed unfair and filters and code can only do so much, so it fell to me to spend days locked into Excel. I’m confident the result was fair and that we will never assume that a small contest played mostly for fun and pride won’t get attacked. My bad for not including the note above on Thursday, but I can assure you of the honesty of the result set since 2 days may not seem like a lot to you but they are an eternity to me. Marty

  • Mariano

    Please inform me when you will create profile pages for each 2011 Top Curator.

    Thanks a lot